Compact Sedans Compared: Hyundai Aura vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor

In the Indian automobile industry, compact sedans almost parallel premium hatchbacks as far as prices are concerned. This is one of the key factors that make them attract buyers who prefer sedans to hatchbacks. Currently, the compact sedan segment sees competition among four contenders: Maruti Dzire, Honda Amaze, Tata Tigor, and Hyundai Aura. Each of them has something special up its sleeve to keep a unique advantage. However, a car’s speciality along with all its other traits should resonate with your needs to become the perfect pick for you. Here is a comparison of all four compact sedans on objective grounds to help you make a sound choice.

Hyundai Aura vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor: Dimensions and Boot

While size is an imperative parameter, compact sedans are more about striking the right balance between size and price. In simple terms, many buyers make do with a slightly smaller size if their pick is significantly affordable. With that being said, there is no dramatic difference among the cars we are comparing, as far as cabin space is concerned.

This dimensions-comparison renders the Maruti Dzire as the most spacious car for passengers, given it is the widest of them all and has the second-longest wheelbase. But its boot space is not as impressive as that of its rivals and can make you consider other options if you want more space for luggage.

The next-best option is the Honda Amaze. While it is 40 mm narrower than the Dzire, it is the second-widest offering and has the longest wheelbase which translates into better space for rear passengers. Moreover, what you will definitely like in the Amaze, is the boot space. The 420-litre of luggage-carrying capacity is the best of them all, making itself quite appealing for many shopping chores as well as family trips.

The Tata Tigor and Hyundai Aura offer more or less the same space in their cabins. A 3 mm difference in width is not enough to make any tangible effect, and both have the same 2,450 mm long wheelbase. However, considering the boot space and headroom, the Tigor is the better option, given it is the tallest of them all and has the second-largest boot space of 419 litres.

For many buyers, the looks of a compact sedan can lay the foundation of their preference so much so that sometimes they tend to lean towards the car they find attractive. Design-wise, the Tata Tigor and Honda Amaze come across as better offerings than the other two. Based on Tata’s Impact 2.0 design language, the fastback silhouette of the Tata Tigor makes it a looker, whereas, the Honda Amaze with its sharp design beautifully encompassing neat panels all around, looks quite elegant from compact sedan standards.

Hyundai Aura vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor: Engine & Transmission

All four contenders are powered by 1.2-litre engines. The Dzire, Aura, and Amaze feature 4-cylinder units, while the Tigor features a 3-cylinder unit. This 3-cylinder Revotron engine has been found to deliver mediocre performance and refinement that make Tigor lag behind its rivals. However, this in no way means that it cannot meet your needs. The Indian sedan is capable of delivering what can be described as convenient driving on city roads as well as on highways.

The Hyundai Aura with its 1.2-litre Kappa engine and Honda Amaze with its 1.2-litre i-VTEC engine drive immensely refined and offer a smooth experience to drivers. Performance-wise, both are considerably better than the Tigor, but still not as exciting as the Maruti Dzire. Also, by missing the CNG-powered engine, the Honda Amaze is at a disadvantage for someone looking for a CNG-powered compact sedan.

Sharing its 1.2-litre DualJet engine with the Maruti Swift, the Dzire delivers the best performance of the lot and drives supremely refined. Moreover, its segment-leading mileage makes it even more attractive as compared to all its rivals.

At the same time, for an automatic powertrain which is required to deliver an effortless driving experience, the Honda Amaze with CVT automatic and paddle shifters, emerges as the best option. Over the years, while AMTs have evolved to their smoothest state, they do not match the convenience level of a CVT automatic.

Hyundai Aura vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor: Features & Comfort

There is no major difference between the feature offerings of all these sedans and to serve a comfortable drive, all of them pack the required features such as automatic climate control, a touchscreen infotainment system and a sound system to keep the drives entertaining. However, some differences are worth considering. For instance, while all these cars offer comfortable seating, the availability of leatherette upholstery in the Tigor’s cabin gives it a premium touch. Moreover, the Indian compact sedan is equipped with an 8-speaker Harman sound system, which is significantly better than rivals in terms of sound quality as well as the number of speakers. In terms of ride comfort, the Tata Tigor and Honda Amaze are a couple of steps ahead of the remaining two, as they do a better job at damping the jerks that come from the surface underneath.

Hyundai Aura vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor: Safety Features

Passenger safety is of paramount importance and in the past few years, the safety standards across the Indian automobile industry, have been raised to the next level. As we look at these cars, it is obvious that each of them features all the essential safety equipment such as ABS with EBD, dual airbags, and rear parking sensors. However, the first and most important layer of the car’s safety is its body shell and thus the Tata Tigor with a 4-star G-NCAP safety rating emerges as the safest of them all. Also, while the facelifted Honda Amaze has not been tested by the G-NCAP, the pre-facelift model which was manufactured in India and sold in Africa, had scored a 4-star rating. Among the remaining two, the Hyundai Aura received a facelift earlier this year and now comes with 4 airbags as standard and 6 airbags in the top variant, making itself a safer offering as compared to the Dzire.

Hyundai Aura vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor: Price comparison

The comparison so far has sketched an interesting drawing and this price comparison fills it with conclusive colours. As can be seen, the Tata Tigor is the most affordable of them all and due to its robust construction, ride quality, large boot, and best sound system, it does emerge as the most value-for-money offering. However, this does not mean that the value it delivers will certainly meet your requirements. It is like you are being offered quality apples at the cheapest possible prices, but you need oranges.

Each of the remaining three offerings has something that might suit your preference. Slightly higher priced than the Tigor, the Hyundai Aura brings a more refined engine and features the greatest number of airbags. Moreover, except for the lower variants, the Maruti Dzire and Honda Amaze are similarly priced. While the Amaze offers better ride quality, a safer bodyshell, the largest boot, and CVT automatic, the Maruti Dzire offers the most spacious cabin, and the best engine that delivers the best mileage.

Hyundai Aura vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor: Summary

With this comparison a choice among these cars should be simple. Of the most affordable options, Tata Tigor should be your pick if passenger safety is your top-most priority and bonus perks that it brings include a large boot, better ride quality, and the best sound system. But, if you need a more refined engine, the Aura will suit you better. Among the other two offerings, Maruti Dzire and Honda Amaze, if you want a spacious as well as cost-efficient car, the Maruti Dzire will serve you well. On the other hand, if you want a safer car or the smoothest automatic transmission, the Honda Amaze is the one to go for.

Hyundai Aura vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor: FAQs

Important Links

7 Seater Cars | Best Mileage Cars | Used Cars In Bangalore | Used Cars In Delhi | Hybrid Cars in India | Sunroof Cars | Used Cars In Gurgaon | Used Cars In Hyderabad | Used Cars In Noida | Used Cars In Pune | CNG Cars in India | Jeeps in India | Used Cars In Mumbai | Used Cars In Ahmedabad | Types of Cars | Car Brands in India | Used Cars In Chennai | Used Cars In Kolkata | Used Cars in Lucknow | Automatic Cars in India | Luxury Cars in India | Used Cars in Chandigarh | Used Cars in Coimbatore | Used Cars in Indore | Used Cars in Jaipur

---