Comparison: Tata Punch vs. Maruti Suzuki Ignis

SUVs are the most desirable cars in India and car makers are developing products for a range of price points. At the same time, compact hatchbacks continue to dominate sales numbers for all leading manufacturers. The answer to this demand is micro SUVs that offer the aesthetics of an SUV in the compact size of a hatchback. The latest to join this unique segment is the Tata Punch micro SUV. In terms of price, the Punch goes up against the Maruti Suzuki Ignis crossover hatchback. This comparison pits the Tata Punch against the Maruti Suzuki Ignis to find which one comes out on top.

Also Read – Maruti Fronx vs Tata Nexon

Table of Contents

• Price Comparison
• On-board Features and Comfort
• Dimensions, Boot and Seating
• Engine and Performance
• Safety Features
• FAQ

Price Comparison

Both cars come in at highly competitive price points. The Tata Punch is aimed at drawing hatchback buyers while the Maruti Ignis offers a unique take on the hatchback formula.

Even though the Tata Punch is priced quite aggressive, the Maruti Suzuki Ignis still offers a price advantage. The top end automatic variant of the Ignis comes at a price of Rs. 8.39 lakh on road, while the same money would fetch you only the mid variant of the Tata Punch. With that said, the price alone only provides half the picture, as the true value can truly be determined when both vehicles go head-to-head in terms of onboard features and comfort.

On-board Features and Comfort

At a time when the SUVs continue to dominate the market, while hatchbacks continue to offer impressive value for money, it was evident that Micro SUVs would be the new trend. However, for any vehicle to connect with the masses, a feature rich cabin and maximum comfort is a must. This is why we have pitched the Tata Punch against the Maruti Suzuki Ignis to compare key comfort and features offered by both the vehicles.

Also Read – Scorpio Classic vs Scorpio N

Evident from the head to head comparison above, both vehicles are equipped with a host of comfort and convenience features that can surely make your driving experience worthwhile. Talking about the Tata Punch, it outruns the Maruti Suzuki Ignis in terms of features like cruise control, cooled glove box, bigger alloys, led tail lamps, 90 degree door opening, leather wrapped steering, rear armrest, 7-inch digital mid, iRA connected car tech, automatic headlamps, rain sensing wipers etc.

However with that said, it is crucial to note that, most of the advanced features offered by the Punch over what the Ignis offers are available from the Creative Trim Onwards which is priced at an on road price starting at Rs. 9.52 lakh, which is Rs. 1.13 lakh more than the on road price of the Ignis’s top-end model.  Therefore as a total package, the Tata Punch does exceptionally well, but for the features it offers over what the Ignis offers, more than a lakh needs to be spent, making the Ignis more Value for money, if features like cruise control and connected car tech can be avoided.

Also Read – Skoda Slavia vs Honda City

Dimensions, Boot and Seating

While these cars are compact by nature, the use of space is important to understand which car will be suited for a growing family. So here’s the Tata Punch head on with the Maruti Suzuki Ignis in terms of exterior dimensions, boot and seating capacity.

As evident from the comparison above, the Tata Punch is longer, wider and taller than the Maruti Suzuki Ignis by a decent margin. This means that those who are looking to buy a micro SUV that is closer in terms of feel to a true-blue SUV then the Tata Punch takes the crown. And since the Punch is the more sizable amongst the two, it also offers bigger boot space and a larger wheelbase that directly translates to better cabin comfort and maximum practicality. The Punch also possesses better ground clearance making it as fun as an SUV can be.

Also Read – Nissan Magnite vs Tata Punch

Engine and Performance

As both these cars are more similar to hatchbacks than traditional compact SUVs, the engines on offer are focused on efficiency rather than outright power. Here, we have pitched the Tata Punch head to head with the Maruti Suzuki Ignis in terms of engine figures, transmission options and mileage, so that you can pick the vehicle that suits you the best.

Both cars offer a 1.2-litre petrol engine with similar power and torque figures. However, Maruti is king of fuel efficiency and the Ignis shines with 20.89 kmpl mileage compared to the Punch’s 18.97 kmpl figure. Apart from this, the Punch offers an additional traction mode on the Automatic which the Ignis misses.

Safety Features

Safety is becoming increasingly important, even in affordable compact cars. Here is how the Tata Punch compares against the Maruti Suzuki Ignis in terms of safety.

Also Read – Maruti Fronx vs Maruti Brezza

The Tata Punch has a clear advantage over the Maruti Ignis in the safety department with a 5-star GNCAP safety rating. The Punch’s stronger chassis is a major contributor to the higher score and should be the easy choice for those prioritizing safety over features. Apart from this both cars are evenly matched when it comes to essential safety features like ISOFIX anchor points and standard dual front airbags.

FAQ

Which is better Tata Punch or Maruti Ignis?

The Tata Punch is better than the Maruti Suzuki Ignis in every aspect except mileage. The Punch has better safety rating, more features, and more space compared to the Ignis.

Which car has better mileage Tata Punch or Maruti Ignis?

The Maruti Suzuki Ignis has a better fuel efficiency of 20.89 kmpl compared to the 18.97 kmpl of the Tata Punch.

What is the GNCAP safety rating of Maruti Ignis?

The Maruti Suzuki Ignis scored 3-star safety rating in the African GNCAP test.

Which is better value Tata Punch or Maruti Ignis?

The Maruti Suzuki Ignis is cheaper than the Tata Punch and offers better value in terms of low maintenance costs as well as better fuel efficiency.

Which is more spacious Tata Punch or Maruti Ignis?

The Tata Punch is more spacious as it is longer and has more interior space for passengers.